Skip to Content

10 of the Best Herbalife Shake Recipes

Herbalife protein shakes are delicious, healthy ways to live your best life and still enjoy a delicious recipe to satisfy your cravings. Here’s how to make Herbalife shake recipes in 10 delicious varieties.

These are the easy, best ideas to use Herbalife shake ingredients in your everyday routine. There is a flavor and a combination for everyone with Herbalife shake ingredients for both Herbalife protein shake recipes and Herbalife smoothie recipes.

These recipes are unique but also familiar and come in a wide variety and range of delicious and nutritious combinations of flavors. These recipes will have something for everyone.

Do you ever feel stumped on how to create a delicious shake or smoothie when you’re trying to lose weight or live a healthier lifestyle?

Herbalife shakes are the perfect solution. Packed with healthy vitamins and supplements and so easy to throw together into a delicious protein shake.

The possibilities are endless for flavors and combinations. You can create all kinds of delicious options. Here are our 10 favorites to try out and take some inspiration to come up with your flavors!

1. Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Shake 

Have you ever put Reese’s peanut butter cup in the freezer and realized it’s better ice cold and creamy?

This shake is like a creamy, delicious ice-cold Reese’s peanut butter cup. The perfect combination of chocolate Herbalife, sugar-free cheesecake mix, and creamy peanut butter.

When you crave sweets and you love peanut butter cups, this will be your new go-to meal or pre-workout to satisfy that craving. It’s delicious, good for your body, and will help you achieve your goals in fitness

2. Birthday Cake shake 

How can you not enjoy a slice of birthday cake? Light, fluffy cake with rainbow sprinkles is the perfect treat to share on a birthday celebration, and now you can work it into your fitness and healthy lifestyle with this birthday cake shake!

This is an easy, delicious, and the best recipe to make an Herbalife shake taste like the classic birthday cake.

All you need is 2 scoops of cookies and cream Herbalife formula, 2 scoops of herbalifepdm formula, 1 teaspoon of cheesecake jello mix, and a dash of sprinkles and ice cubes.

Blended until silky smooth, this Herbalife protein shake recipe is not only easy but will also have you ready to take on your day and not feel the least bit of guilt after enjoying a sweet treat.

3. Cinnabon Shake 

Have you ever eaten a Cinnabon cinnamon roll? If you have, you know how insanely delicious they are.

If you haven’t then you must try this shake! Either way, you need to try this shake because it’s got all those warm cinnamon flavors of those rolls but is healthy and the best way to jumpstart your body for fitness and just for life!

All you need to know how to make this Herbalife protein shake, is the Herbalife cookies and cream formula, vanilla PDM formula, ice cubes, water, and a dash of cinnamon.

You’ll have yourself a lusciously creamy shake that really tastes like a Cinnabon!

4. Cinnamon Toast Crunch Shake 

What’s the next best thing after a cinnamon roll..? Cinnamon toast crunch cereal!

The way the milk gets all sweet and spiced when you eat that cereal is the same exact thing that this Herbalife protein shake delivers.

You will have to make this one, again and again, I promise. The best thing about Herbalife protein is that it comes in so many different flavors so you can really get creative with recipes.

This Herbalife smoothie uses the dulce de leche and vanilla flavors, with a little cheesecake powder, graham cracker crumb, and of course, cinnamon.

Blended together till smooth and then topped with a little sprinkle of graham cracker crumbs you will feel like you’re diving into a bowl of cinnamon toast crunch for sure, and not feel any guilt about it.

5. Peanut Butter Cheesecake Shake

Imagine a peanut butter cup gets turned into a cheesecake, that then becomes a milkshake! Can you get any more delicious and indulgent than that?

This shake is the ultimate win for peanut butter lovers everywhere, and you don’t weigh yourself down like a traditional peanut butter cheesecake.

Simply blend together, 2 scoops of Vanilla Herbalife protein formula, with 2 scoops of formula 1 Herbalife vanilla, a tablespoon of peanut butter, and 1 tsp of sugar-free cheesecake pudding powder.

Sprinkle a few graham crackers on the top and you’ve got yourself a decadent meal to satisfy all your peanut butter cravings at no cost to your health or fitness for the day.

6. Mint Chocolate Chip Shake 

An underrated player in the ice cream flavor game: mint chocolate chip. It’s classic and it’s really good, but no one is hyping up mint chocolate chips, until now!

Do you love chocolate? Do you love ice cream? Then you must try this recipe and see if it fits your flavor game.

Extra protein and potassium are added with a whole banana blended into the mix. Just combine Herbalife vanilla protein powder with some soy milk, semi-sweet chocolate chips, mint extract, and a banana for this unique and delicious meal to sustain you through the day.

Who knows! Maybe you’ll become a mint chocolate chip believer.

7. Wedding Cake Shake 

Ok, wedding cake gets a bad read because people always think it’s just a beautiful cake but it doesn’t actually taste good.

Wrong! A wedding cake can be so delicious, with white chocolate and vanilla frosting and that fluffy white cake under all that gorgeous decoration.

This shake is all that and more, whether you’re married or not! You’ll enjoy this wedding cake-flavored Herbalife protein shake recipe.

8. Snickers Shake

Imagine a snickers ice cream bar, meet the classic snickers in shake form and you’ve got this phenomenal snickers flavored Herbalife protein shake recipe for your next meal.

You don’t need to feel any guilt slurping down this decadent shake because it’s low-fat low-carb and good for you to continue on a health journey or just maintain a healthy lifestyle.

Using Herbalife’s chocolate flavor protein formula you can create so many different flavors, but this snickers version is a showstopper.

Just combine the chocolate formula with low-fat cottage cheese, almond milk, peanut butter, sugar-free caramel syrup, and a little cocoa powder.

Topped with a couple of peanuts and a drizzle of sugar-free chocolate syrup and you’ve got yourself a treat.

9. Smores Shake 

Is there anyone out there that doesn’t love a S’more?? It’s the best part of a campfire, and a classic flavor combination and that is sure to give you nostalgia and summertime vibes.

This Herbalife shake recipe delivers on all those things.

The combination of the chocolate flavor of Herbalife’s PDM line, with the cookies and cream protein, and vanilla protein, makes for the perfect s’mores flavor.

You can even get real indulgent with it and put a little bit of marshmallow syrup into the mix for the full effect.

Herbalife Shake

10 of the best Herbalife Shake Recipes

Prep Time: 5 minutes
Total Time: 5 minutes

Do you ever feel stumped on how to create a delicious shake or smoothie when you're trying to lose weight or just live a healthier lifestyle?


  • 1 1/2 tsp lemon juice
  • 1 pouch Alpine Original Spiced Apple Cider Mix
  • 2 scoops vanilla ice cream


  1. To make this alpine apple pie shake you’ll need one packet of apple cider mix, 1 teaspoon of lemon juice, and 2 scoops of vanilla Herbalife protein mix.
  2. In a blender, combine the apple cider mix, lemon juice, scoops of vanilla, and a handful of ice cubes.
  3. Add in 1 cup of water and blend until smooth and creamy. Serve in a chilled glass with a drizzle of sugar-free caramel syrup on top.

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Pinterest

Skip to Recipe