Skip to Content

The Best 20 Sandwich Maker Recipes for Every Occasion

Whenever I made myself a sandwich, my mom would say: “Eat real food. A sandwich is not a proper meal.” I think she’s wrong. A sandwich can be a full meal if you do it right, and you can add anything you want to it. Customize it with as many ingredients as you can wish.

I bought a sandwich press with my first paycheck. “What can you make in a sandwich maker”? She asked. Well, I came up with so many sandwich-maker recipes, that in the end she was as hooked as me!

I have compiled a list of 20 amazing sandwich press recipes for you to enjoy. If you don’t own a sandwich maker, don’t waste more time, go get one and find out what my obsession was all about!

1. Chipotle chicken panini sandwich

If you like spicy food, you will love the chipotle sauce in this panini. This is one of my favorite

Sandwich toaster recipes. Two sourdough bread slices are slathered in a sauce made with Dijon mustard, sweet hot mustard, and chipotle mayo.

Stuffed with cooked chicken, crispy bacon, tomato slices, and cheese, this mouthwatering panini will satisfy your cravings!


2. Monte Cristo Sandwich

One of the all-time nostalgic sandwich-maker recipes. It’s a ham and cheese sandwich that is dipped in an egg batter and then pan-fried or pressed in a sandwich maker. The outside layer of the bread is crispy while the inside stays custardy soft.

Once you bite it, the gooey cheese and deli ham will just melt in your mouth!


3. Tomato and Avocado Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Why mess with simple perfection? This is one of the easiest panini recipes you can think of.

Colby Jack, mashed avocado with lemon, and tomato slices are pressed until toasted on the outside and melted on the inside.

This is the perfect recipe for those days when you don’t have time to cook or are craving the perfect snack.


4. Chicken Parm Panini

Are you a lover of Italian food? Me too, and Chicken Parmigiana is one of my favorite dishes, so naturally, I think a Chicken Parm panini is a brilliant idea!

No breading or frying necessary! Shredded cooked chicken, mozzarella cheese, and sauteed mushrooms, garlic, and onions are sandwiched between marinara sauce-slathered bread sliced, and then pressed until toasty and melted!


5. Maple Bacon Grilled Cheese

If you are looking for things to make in a sandwich maker, let me present you with the ultimate grilled cheese sandwich.

Thick slices of bacon are brushed with a delicious glaze made with maple syrup, brown sugar, balsamic vinegar, Dijon mustard, and a pinch of cayenne and baked until crispy and caramelized.


6. Panera Steak and White Cheddar Panini

Deli roast beef is paired with pickled onions, horseradish mayo, and white cheddar cheese to make a tangy, cheesy, and meaty delight!

This fantastic panini will leave you wanting more. One bite and you will be hooked for life. You will want to make it again and again!


7. Mushroom and Goat Cheese Veggie Panini

If you want healthy sandwich maker recipes, add this mushroom and goat cheese veggie panini to your list.

Red onion, crimini mushrooms, garlic, goat cheese, balsamic vinegar, roasted bell peppers, and arugula make the perfect combo. This delicious concoction can be made using focaccia, sourdough, or ciabatta.


8. The Best Cuban Sandwich Recipe

If you’ve never tried a Cuban sandwich, you’re in for a treat! This recipe for Cuban Mojo-marinated pork roast makes the best meat for sandwich press recipes.

After you make the pork roast, you can stuff it between two slices of bread rolls along with sliced ham, swiss cheese, dill pickles, and mustard. DELICIOUS!


9. Pizza Panini

Making pizza in panini form is a quick and easy way to satisfy your cravings!

Use mini pizza crusts, or flatbreads and add your favorite pizza toppings along with pizza sauce, slices of mozzarella, and grated parmesan cheese… yum! Don’t forget to season it with oregano and red pepper flakes!


10. Nutella Bacon French Toast Panini

Your breakfast sandwich maker just got lucky with this mouth-watering panini recipe. Your family will love you for this!

Make French toast and use it as the bread in the sandwich. Spread it with Nutella and place cooked bacon in between two slices, butter on top, and press!

You will not believe how delicious this breakfast panini is!


11. Eggplant Panini

Another vegetarian delight! Grilled seasoned eggplant is paired with sauteed sun-dried tomatoes that are cooked with balsamic vinegar and white wine until caramelized, provolone cheese, and spinach.

The flavor of the veggies is made even better by the gooey cheese and the toasted, pressed bread slices!


12. Caprese Panini with Avocado Basil Pesto

A special pesto made with avocado, pine nuts, basil, lemon juice, Parmesan cheese, garlic, and olive oil makes this caprese panini special.

The addition of avocado makes it creamy and lush! Spread the pesto over sourdough slices and assemble your caprese panini. Place it in the sandwich press and voila! A perfect panini!


13. Bbq Chicken Panini Sandwiches

Whether you use store-bought pulled chicken or make it yourself in the slow cooker, using it to make paninis is a genius idea.

You can add coleslaw or just pickles, but don’t skimp on the Havarti cheese! This panini comes together so quickly, you can make a bunch of them for a party or get-together using your sandwich maker!


14. Apple, Arugula, and Brie Panini

Creamy Brie cheese, thin-sliced green apples, and arugula all melt together between slices of buttered sourdough bread to produce the most amazing gourmet-style panini.

The bread needs to be buttered to get perfectly toasted, but the butter used in this recipe is mixed with honey, so the bread is not only toasted but caramelized!


15. Meatloaf Panini

Made meatloaf and you have leftovers? Make a panini! You can add anything you want to this basic meatloaf panini!

This basic recipe using meatloaf, cheese, mayo, and butter can be glammed up with sliced olives, pepperoncini, roasted red peppers, tomato slices, or anything you want!

Meatloaf panini is the best way to use your leftovers!

16. Mediterranean Panini

What can be more Mediterranean than artichoke hearts, sun-dried tomatoes, and pesto?

These delicious ingredients mixed with chicken breast, spinach, and mozzarella make the most scrumptious of paninis!

Simple, easy-to-find ingredients that when combined, make magic! Put your sandwich press to good use and make some for dinner tonight!


17. Grilled California Chicken Wraps

What can you make using a sandwich maker? Wraps! Sandwich makers can be used to make wraps too! You can use tortillas, waffles, and even shredded cheese instead of bread.

Chopped chicken, shredded cheese, bacon bits, avocado slices, chopped green onions, and ranch dressing are wrapped in flour tortillas and pressed until crispy. Want one?


18. Turkey and Brie Croissant Panini

Croissants can also be used to make paninis. This is a perfect way to use your Thanksgiving leftovers. Slices of turkey breast, cranberry sauce or relish, creamy brie cheese, and fresh arugula leaves make the best after-Thanksgiving lunch.

You could even sneak some mashed potatoes or sweet potato casserole in too!

19. Italian Style Panini

This list wouldn’t be complete without an Italian-style panini!

Salami, Soppressata, Prosciutto, Mortadella, and sliced Mozzarella cheese are just a few ingredients you can use to make an authentic Italian panini. Of course, you could add sliced pepperoncini peppers, a drizzle of olive oil, fresh basil, or oregano… the possibilities are endless!

20. Puff Pastry Toasted Sandwiches

Using puff pastry for mini sandwich maker recipes is a great idea.

Puff pastry stuffed with onion, chives, tomatoes, ham, and mashed potatoes (or veggies like peas and potatoes spiced with curry), makes the perfect finger food for a party!

Super easy to make, these triangle sandwich maker recipe ideas will make your appetizer-making experience a breeze!

Sandwiches ARE the perfect finger food. You can use any ingredient you want, and take them anywhere with you. You can eat them for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. You can make one, or make a dozen. Meals, appetizers, you name it.

Sandwich Maker Recipes

The Best 20 Sandwich Maker Recipes for Every Occasion

Puff Pastry Toasted Sandwiches - A super simple recipe
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 20 minutes
Total Time 20 minutes
Course Sandwiches
Cuisine American
Servings 2 Sandwiches


  • 1 sheet of store-bought puff pastry, cut to squares to a size that fits the sandwich maker
  • 2 tablespoons butter, melted
  • ¼ cup shredded gruyere cheese
  • ¼ cup chopped ham
  • 1 teaspoon chopped chives
  • 2 tablespoons leftover mashed potatoes
  • teaspoon paprika
  • teaspoon oregano
  • Salt and pepper to taste


  • In a small bowl, combine the gruyere cheese, chopped ham, chives, mashed potatoes, paprika, oregano, salt, and pepper.
  • Brush the inside of the sandwich maker with melted butter (top and bottom)
  • Place a square of puff pastry in the bottom parts of the sandwich maker
  • Place half of the filling over each square
  • Top with the other couple of puff pastry squares and press until toasted
Recipe Rating


Wednesday 27th of December 2023